With the skincare diet trend going around, I was super intrigued by the possibility of condensing my typically two-part cleansing routine to just one step with the ECO YOUR SKIN Oil to Foam Cleanser. Both categories of products have their own merits and functions but saving time is always on the back of my mind. The concept is pretty new and not many brands have anything like it. After finishing the entire bottle of cleanser I think I can safely say it is an idea which isn't quite there yet.
Peach & Lily's description:
Instead of relying on sulfates, this cleanser utilizes coconut fruit extract as the natural cleansing agent to create suds that are rich yet mild on skin. Micro-bubbles help deep clean pores of makeup, residue and sunscreen. Aromatic oils like wild geranium and Moroccan wild chamomile help boost hydration so skin is left perfectly balanced and clean.
Directions
Apply the foam onto dry skin and massage gently before rinsing with tepid water. Optional: leave the foam on for 2 minutes as necessary to brighten skin tone.
Ingredients
CARBONATED WATER, WATER, TEA-COCOYL GLUTAMATE, GLYCERIN, PEG-7 GLYCERYL COCOATE, BUTYLENE GLYCOL, METHYLPROPANEDIOL, POTASSIUM COCOYL GLYCINATE, COCAMIDOPROPYL BETAINE, COCAMIDE DEA, 1,2-HEXANEDIOL, BETAINE, PENTYLENE GLYCOL, CAPRYLYL GLYCOL, CALENDULA OFFICINALIS FLOWER WATER, GERANIUM MACULATUM OIL, ORMENIS MULTICAULIS OIL, ALOE BARBADENSIS LEAF EXTRACT, CUCUMIS SATIVUS (CUCUMBER) FRUIT EXTRACT, CAMELLIA SINENSIS LEAF EXTRACT, LEONURUS SIBIRICUS FLOWER/LEAF/STEM EXTRACT, ALGAE EXTRACT, CAULERPA LENTILLIFERA EXTRACT, ENTEROMORPHA COMPRESSA EXTRACT, UNDARIA PINNATIFIDA EXTRACT, ECKLONIA CAVA EXTRACT, POLYSORBATE20, ALLANTOIN, DIPOTASSIUM GLYCYRRHIZATE, ETHYLHEXYLGLYCERIN, CITRIC ACID, ASPALATHUS LINEARIS EXTRACT, GLYCYRRHIZA GLABRA (LICORICE) ROOT EXTRACT, CI 42090, CI 19140
Cleanser 170 ml
ECO YOUR SKIN (Korean retail): ₩30,000
Peach & Lily: USD $34.00
Packaging
New bottles of cleanser come in a sealed box to ensure its safety. The foaming pump bottle is fairly standard and does a great job at dispensing uniformly aerated bubbles. See-through packaging is always a plus in my books. ECO YOUR SKIN also paid attention to the small details such as having the tube inside be curved to allow every last drop of cleanser to be used.
Color, Texture, Finish, & Scent
While the liquid inside the bottle is a bright green color, the foam that comes out is mostly white with a slight tinge of green. Unlike the foam created by foaming nets and cups, this pumping mechanism produces a very light and airy lather which means it also tends to deflate quickly. The cleanser has a very strong and lingering herby scent due to all the extracts and essential oils.
Foam on clean/bare skin will stay fluffy until it is rubbed onto the skin. Interestingly, foam on dirty/product-laden skin will immediately dissipate into a runny liquid texture. Perhaps this is due to the surfactants in its formulation? The cleanser ultimately washes away easily without leaving the skin too tight or dry. Whether there is leftover product residue depends widely on what I am trying to cleanse off (skincare only versus light- versus heavy makeup).
How I Apply
1. Use after removing makeup/waterproof sunscreen with cleansing balm or oil.
2. Make sure my hands and face are mostly dry.
3. Pump 5-6 times into the palm of my hands.
4. Transfer onto my face and slowly massage all over.
5. Rinse well.
Thoughts & Recommendations
Even the name "Oil to Foam Cleanser" kind of seems to suggest the product to be a 2-in-1. However, the Peach & Lily ladies at the sample sale last year suggested it is to be used how I would any other foaming cleanser—after a makeup remover and not in place of one. The ingredients don't suggest it is oil based either, instead carbonated water and water are the top-most components. The others that follow are mainly surfactants and solvents. "Oils" only show up in the form of a couple of essential oils (geranium and chamomile) further down the list.
Therefore, using it as a water-based cleanser is precisely how I emptied most of the bottle of cleanser liquid. I like the product a lot in this manner. The foam definitely makes cleansing a more gentle and lush-feeling process. I would prefer if the bubbles were denser though because it dissipates too fast. Otherwise, it removes cleansing balm residue well without stripping my face and had no bad skin reactions. I can't say if it stings my eyes or not because I tend to keep them shut until it is completely rinsed off.
There were a few times I gave it the duty of cleaning waterproof, "mineral" sunscreen off my hands after application. It surprisingly works very well for the task—far more efficient than a typical hand soap but not as heavy-duty nor messy as a cleansing oil.
On an occasion or two, I tested it for any makeup cleansing abilities on light makeup days. I cannot say I was disappointed because I honestly didn't expect it to remove much. Let's just say I would not recommend it as a replacement for any removing liquid, oil, or balm.
I think a big factor in whether someone would like this particular product or not lies in the small details:
- You have to think of it as a water-based, post-makeup remover cleanser.
- The auto-foaming ability is nice and saves some time from having to manually create the suds.
- Less dense foam means a shorter cleansing time, which can be a good or bad thing.
- The smell isn't terrible but can be overwhelming since it lingers for as long as it is on the face.
- One bottle of liquid foaming cleanser doesn't last nearly as long as a tube of non-liquid cleanser.
Unfortunately, consolidating my cleansing routine in such a manner won't be happening any time soon. It did reopen my eyes to the world of self-foaming cleansers. Perhaps if I were to try another one it'd be a less expensive and less fragranced (even if "natural") option.
March is always a tough month for me when it comes to spending. Most purchases are fueled by the thought of, it's my birthday just once a year. What's a little splurge?
I like to think I did alright this time around. Of the items I actually paid for, half were to replace product categories I constantly use up (cleanisng balm and cleanser) and the other half was completely impulsive (highlighter stick and cream blush). The other items were "free" with point usage.
Glossier Cloud paint - Dusk
Glossier Haloscope - Quartz
Glossier Milky Jelly Cleanser
Sephora Beauty Insider Birthday Gift - Drunk Elephant edition
AMOREPACIFIC Treatment Enzyme Peeling Masque
LANEIGE Lip Sleeping Mask
BANILA CO. Clean It Zero Cleansing Balm - Nourishing
I never thought there would come a day I would try a cleansing balm I did not like. Okay, I'm sorry, that is a bit overdramatic—I haven't tried that many compared to what's available on the market. But you get the idea right? Most tend to look, feel, and/or perform more or less the same. FEMMUE's Extraordinary Beauty Cleansing Balm gives the most different user experience from start to finish that is too unconventional for me to adapt to.
FEMMUE's description:
Just simple rolling massage with Femmue's Balm relieves your body and mind fatigued by stress during the day, just like you are in a spa. The mild heat created during the balm massage melts bodily waste and dead skin cells blocking the skin pores while offering ample nourishment. It offers wonderful softness and radiance to the skin. Femmue's unique gel-type cleansing balm changes from jelly to oil and emulsion form when applied, allowing diverse massaging and cleansing for users. It also soothes and enriches your mind with its mild ylang-ylang fragrance and fresh citrus and woody fragrance.
Olive Oil: Mildly cleanses off makeup while changing its formulation during application. With vitamin E helping strike oil-moisture balance for the skin, it is excellent for skin soothing.
Evening Primrose Oil, Rosa Canina Fruit Oil, Macadamia Oil, Avocado Oil: The plant-based oils help create a moisturizing shield and retain long-lasting skin hydration.
No artificial fragrance, no artificial color additive, no chemical surfactant, no preservatives ensure minimal skin irritation and perfect comfort for the skin.
The natural skin protective shield created by the product ensures hydration even after facial wash while preserving the natural skin lipids and moisture.
Directions
Scoop about a dime-size dollop onto hands and rub between fingers.
Gently massage onto dry skin.
Use tepid water to emulsify oil and rinse away.
Ingredients
GLYCERIN, OLEA EUROPAEA (OLIVE) FRUIT OIL, MINERAL OIL, DIGLYC- ERIN, SUCROSE STEARATE, POLOXAMER 184, POLYGLYCERYL-10 BEHENATE/EICOSADI- OATE, BEESWAX, CETEARYL ALCOHOL, WATER, GLYCERYL BEHENATE/EICOSADIOATE, GLYCERYL STEARATE, OLEA EUROPAEA (OLIVE) FRUIT EXTRACT, TOCOPHERYL ACETATE, OENOTHERA BIENNIS (EVENING PRIMROSE) OIL, ROSA CANINA FRUIT OIL, MACADAMIA TERNIFOLIA SEED OIL, PERSEA GRATISSIMA (AVOCADO) OIL, HELIANTHUS ANNUUS (SUNFLOWER) SEED OIL UNSAPONIFIABLES, CANANGA ODORATA FLOWER OIL, PEL- ARGONIUM GRAVEOLENS OIL, LAVANDULA ANGUSTIFOLIA (LAVENDER) OIL, JUNIP- ERUS MEXICANA OIL, CITRUS LIMON (LEMON) PEEL OIL, CITRUS AURANTIUM DULCIS (ORANGE) PEEL OIL, LAURUS NOBILIS LEAF OIL, SALVIA SCLAREA (CLARY) OIL, AMYRIS BALSAMIFERA BARK OIL, CITRUS AURANTIUM BERGAMIA (BERGAMOT) FRUIT OIL, V- ANILLA PLANIFOLIA FRUIT EXTRACT, CINNAMOMUM ZEYLANICUM BARK OIL, ROSA DAMASCENA FLOWER EXTRACT, GLYCERYL CAPRYLATE, SODIUM DILAURAMIDOGL- UTAMIDE LYSINE, CAPRYLYL GLYCOL
Balm 50 ml / 1.76 oz
FEMMUE (Korean retail): ₩45,000
FEMMUE (American retail): USD $46.00
Peach & Lily: USD $38.00
Packaging
A thick and hefty frosted-glass jar with a screw on cap. New tubs of cleansing balm should include an inner seal but sadly lacks a spatula for something that is supposedly more luxe. Although pretty to look at on the counter, it is not the best for travel because of the weight and delicate nature of glass.
Color, Texture, Finish, & Scent
The texture of the Femmue's cleansing balm is by far the most unique I have tried. It is transparent and bright yellow in color, which is supposedly all natural. The balm is very thick and resistant to scooping, unlike the softer "sorbet" varieties that are more common; the closest comparison I can say would be a cross between Vaseline and Smith's Rosebud Salve. Emulsifying and rinsing off the makeup remover requires more effort whilst not giving the cleanest feeling afterward. There is a very strong floral scent that doesn't dissipate until it is fully washed off.
How I Apply
1. Scoop an appropriate amount (varies depending on how much makeup I had put on my face).
2. Massage it gently all over. Focus on crevices and areas with a higher concentration of colors.
3. Sometimes wet my hands a little and emulsify the balm.
4. Continuously splash my face with water to fully rinse dissolved makeup and balm away.
5. (For me personally) Must follow up with a cleanser after.
Thoughts & Recommendations
All the little things that make the Extraordinary Beauty Cleansing Balm unique are what I found to be most cumbersome. This isn't any rash judgment either as I bore through the entire jar of balm.
I believe Femmue chose to have it be such a thick type balm to elevate the textural sensation in order to match its luxurious image. They want it to be spa-like and encourages facial massaging, which a rich & shiny balm seems fitting for. My issue with it is how body heat doesn't ever "melt" the cleansing balm as much as one would imagine. It just smooths onto the skin as if I am spreading out a layer of lip balm all over my face. Too little balm and I would tug at my skin when removing makeup; too much product and I would feel overwhelmed by the heaviness.
Femmue says the product is formulated to leave a "protective shield" to seal in natural facial oils and moisture. If that is the reason why the balm leaves a slick oily finish even after persistent rinsing, I could have done without the shield. My skin isn't ever dried out with the product and there is a soft quality after. I also know that a squeaky clean face is a no-go but the finish I get is more similar to when I try to clean an oily dish with just plain tap water—in my opinion, just doesn't work.
While most of the cleansing balms I have reviewed so far did a poor job against fresh waterproof pen liner, they ultimately did great against worn-out waterproof pen liner that was mixed with my oily eyelids. The Femmue balm is the only one so far to require a lot more attention with massaging and rubbing yet working not as well. Sometimes the more I massage (just lightly with my ring fingers) the more the balm would end up irritating and stinging my eyes, which is a completely new experience for me with any balm.
Otherwise the strong floral scent isn't so bad that it would give me headaches. Perhaps those more sensitive would not like it. I am just glad to say the cleansing balm never broke me out or irritated my skin, even with all the essential oils in its formulation. It does a good enough job at removing worn-out, non-waterproof makeup and sunscreen too.
Since I didn't enjoy using the product, I was glad the jar only had 50ml of product and that I bought it at a steep discount from the Peach & Lily sample sale. If I had enjoyed the balm more the 50ml would have been disappointingly small to be almost USD $40. Least to say, I will not be repurchasing another of the Femmue cleansing balm in the future. I do seem to be in the minority as many do rave of it on the Peach & Lily website.
